There is a tempting belief about the Someday list, that it is a safe place. A project moved there has been taken out of play, no longer competes for time or needs attention, and will wait harmlessly until a later version of you has room. The list is a shelf, and things on a shelf cost nothing. David Allen’s Getting Things Done calls it the Someday/Maybe list. But what the shelf actually holds is two different kinds of things, and only one is harmless.
The first kind is a true backlog, that is, work you have decided not to do yet. A true backlog really does cost nothing. Your decision has a reason you could state and a sense of when the work might come back. There is no outstanding promise to anyone, including yourself, that it is happening. It is a note, not a tenant.
The second is an undecided obligation, or work you moved to Someday precisely to avoid deciding about it. It still carries a promise, to you or someone else, and still comes to mind with the sense that you’re failing at something. Every new project is silently compared with the Someday projects it would displace, and the current work feels like one option among several rather than the thing, without you noticing.
The test for which kind you are looking at is quite simple. Pick an item on the list and imagine telling someone, out loud, that you are not going to do it. If that sentence is easy and true then the item is backlog and was never costing you anything. If the sentence is hard, produces guilt, or you immediately start adding qualifiers — not yet, not this year, not until — then the item was never decided, and has been running in the background this whole time.
A Someday list can contain a surprising number of undecided obligations. That is not a failure of discipline: the list can become a place where undecided things go so they can stop being looked at. But not looking does not itself settle the decision. The cost is paid daily, and keeps adding up anyway.
A test small enough to do on the walk home
Tonight, run the one-sentence test above on the top five items of your list and count how many sentences were easy. That number is probably your actual backlog. The rest is work you have been doing without noticing, and it could use a real decision. The Attention-Rent Ledger, the member tool published October 28, does this for every open project at once.



